Six Sent Off as Late Brawl Ends Club America Friendly Against Red Bulls

Photo: Sam Szapucki / CC BY 2.0 (via Wikimedia Commons).

Club America’s friendly against the New York Red Bulls in Harrison ended in a mass brawl on Saturday night, with six players sent off in the closing minutes and both teams finishing the match with eight men.

The Red Bulls won 1-0, but the result was overtaken by the fight. The Red Bulls’ official match report records three red cards for each team after the melee in the 85th minute.

What happened

The spark, in ESPN’s account of the incident, was a foul near America’s area and a confrontation over Adrián Fernández, the young substitute who had come on in the second half.

Devin Padelford grabbed Fernández by the neck, and Emilio Lara came to his teammate’s defense. ESPN reported that Lara struck Padelford, and the confrontation became a general fight.

Andy Rojas threw punches in the melee. USA Today reported that footage from the match showed Rojas punching Dagoberto Espinoza in the back of the head, and a New York Post photo caption likewise showed Rojas throwing a punch at Espinoza.

Both benches emptied, the fight moved toward one of the corners, and fans threw projectiles onto the field. Play was stopped for several minutes before the match resumed and finished eight against eight.

Guillermo Almada tried to approach the referee during the stoppage, and his own players held him back, according to ESPN and Infobae.

The six players sent off

For Club America, the referee sent off Emilio Lara, Ramón Juárez and Dagoberto Espinoza. The club itself announced those three dismissals during the match.

For the Red Bulls, the three were Ronald Donkor, Nehuén Benedetti and Andy Rojas. Benedetti had scored the only goal just before the hour, finishing the rebound after Rodolfo Cota saved Julián Bazán’s volley from Rafael Mosquera’s cross, and he ended the night sent off as well.

Some early reports put the total at eight expulsions. The Red Bulls’ official match report records three red cards per team, and the official count is three per team.

Red Bulls head coach Michael Bradley addressed the brawl at his post-match press conference. “It was a game and a night that we were really excited for, and so at the end of the game you get some emotion that spills over,” Bradley said. “It’s part of it on certain nights.”

Club America had not issued a statement on the brawl as of Sunday, and Almada had not commented on it publicly.

What it means for the Tigres UANL finale

The three dismissed players are defenders, and the question hanging over the week is whether any of them is at risk for the regular season finale at Tigres UANL on November 21.

As of Sunday, no disciplinary body had announced a sanction over the brawl. A red card in a friendly does not by itself carry a suspension into Liga MX, so Lara, Juárez and Espinoza remain available unless a disciplinary body opens a case and rules otherwise.

Club America finish first only with a win at Estadio Universitario and Cruz Azul failing to beat Chivas de Guadalajara; if Chivas de Guadalajara and Cruz Azul draw, America and Cruz Azul would be level on 33 points if America win, and first place would be decided on goal difference.

The full match report from Harrison is in the recap of the 1-0 loss. For the full U.S. viewing picture for every Águilas match, see the Club America watch page.